Review – Ys: The Oath in Felghana

Ys: The Oath in Felghana is a modern remake of Ys 3, one of the more radical entries in Falcom’s long running franchise.  While the first two games were top down adventures in the same vein as Zelda 1, Ys3 is a side scroller similar to Zelda 2.  The promotional website for Oath in Felghana goes into detail as to what the remake entails, stressing that it expands upon the original without heavy alterations or retconning.  I can’t say for certain if it succeeds in this regard, but I can take a guess, because Oath is an excellent game on its own.  It has an old school charm without feeling arcahic, yet it is a careful update that avoids adding the cruft and excesses of modern games.

Oath in Felghana once again stars series heroes Adol and Dogi, who have continued adventuring together after the events of Ys 1 and 2.  Their journeys take them to Dogi’s homeland of Felghana, where bad things are going on.  Naturally Adol takes up his sword and swears to put things back to normal.  The story is simple (as is typical of Ys games), but also heartfelt.  The cast is small enough that even the bit players have some character to them, and events unfold via a minimum amount of cutscenes and dialogue.  It serves as a welcome distraction rather than an obstacle to the action.

Most jRPG’s are traditionally structured around towns, and the feeling of safety they evoke. You brave the dangers of the overworld in order to reach the next town, which then becomes your “base camp” of sorts as you gear up for a journey into the local dungeon.  Oath in Felghana’s main town eschews this traditional structure.  You don’t have to go there to heal, and while you sometimes return to advance the story, this doesn’t occur after every single dungeon. The town mainly exists to serve up a handful of sidequests and equipment upgrades.  In this way, it exists as more of a pit stop than a refuge.

The rest of your time, then, is spent fighting and exploring.  Like in Ys 3, the combat system apes Zelda 2, complete with upward and downward sword thrusts. While simple in structure, the combat remains challenging throughout.  The bestiary is crafted around every one of Adol’s abilities, such that certain monsters can only be damaged via a certain move.  At the same time, your foes have a tendency to work in a group, keeping pressure on you from the moment you enter a room.  Thus both offense and defense require care and precision; failure to apply either will likely result in the player being caught in a wave of attacks which can easy kill you.

This is only possible due to careful manipulation of player stats.  Adol’s health improves when he levels up, but not by very much.  So throughout the game, an enemy that deals 25 — 30 HP worth of damage is a significant threat.  This is compounded by the fact that enemies are stingy with healing items, and one of Ys’ staple features — the ability to regenerate health when standing still — is only obtained via a secret item.  The only reliable way to stay alive is to level up (which fills your HP meter), and the only way to level up is to stay alive long enough to kill enough monsters.  Skill simply has no substitute here.

To be sure, evel ups do make a tremendous difference.  When it comes to some of the more challenging bosses, they can make the difference between victory and defeat.  By the time you finish a dungeon, you’ll be able to overpower all the enemies within, but by this point they’ll be less than meaningless to you, dishing out paltry sums of XP and money.  You’ll need to move on to the next area and its new batch of challenges.  Combat in Oath never feels desperate, but it is always tense, and its unrelenting nature will keep players on their toes until the very end.

Oath in Felghana was originally released on PC, making the PSP version a port (though a port handled directly by Falcom). For the most part, the game is right at home on the handheld.   The controls are a little awkward in certain situations, though there are options which can be toggled to make them more manageable. Visually, the character sprites have that rough, lo-res look of early 2000 games like Diablo 2, and are one of the only clues that this isn’t a native PSP game.  Yet the visuals are hardly ugly; the colors are vibrant, and the architecture does enough to craft a unique mood for each dungeon. Perhaps most important to the game’s presentation is Falcom’s decision to include two old soundtrack arrangements from Ys 3, which can be switched between on the fly.  To be honest, I enjoyed the new soundtrack the most, as they heighten the tension and tone intended for each area.  Yet I am grateful for the old chiptunes as well, since they contain details which the new arrangements often omit.  Together, the soundtracks demonstrate that live musicians can evoke more powerful emotions, but those old sound chips can evoke sounds that human performers would struggle to eke out of their instrument.  And yes, the music truly is as good as I was told.

With only a month left in 2010, I have no qualms with saying that Oath in Felghana is one of my favorite games this year.  It is a rare release which uses modern technology to enhance an old game, rather than to scrub the old out.  The story is expanded, but it isn’t chatty.  The quest is longer, but it still isn’t overly long (my first playthrough was around 15 hours, without a moment of boredom).   It feels like an antique which was polished up and put back on display, rather than a modern replacement made of shoddy materials.  I’m glad to see that Falcom is proud of their past accomplishments in an age where most developers are all too eager to destroy the past in a sea of retcons and tweaks.  Ys 3 may have been imperfect, but now it has been made into a genuine classic.

Please do our advertising for us:
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
12 years ago

great review.

i have played ys 1, 2, and 6 and one thing i think the series does really is balancing difficulty with a respect for the players time. in many rpgs, returning to early (easy) areas in the game is still a time consuming process since turn based battles can only be so fast. in the early ys games you basically run through enemies to kill them so while they are tough the first time you encounter them, you can move through early areas about as quickly as your running speed by the time you have leveled up a bunch. related to this is how you mentioned the dungeons and especially bosses are balanced. it seems like falcom decides for you what level you should be when you fight a boss. a level or two too low and you will barely be able to damage him, and you wont be able to get a level or two too high because one you level a few times in a particular dungeon enemies give you an insignificant amount of exp.

i know ys 3 is a departure for the series, but i take it from your review that this balance i enjoy so much is preserved in the game.

12 years ago

Ys 3 is the only one I had played until Ark of Napishtim (so I’ve played 3, 6, 7 and maybe an hour of 1 on PC).

Does Oath preserve everything? No. Ys3 was a hellish grind in which you will spend at least half an hour making a half-jump to gradually whittle down enemies (half-serious naturally). You have to spend tons of time killing the first few enemies in a new area to level up enough that you can safely enter that section. This worked until the final area: even once you maxed levels, the enemies there would STILL kill you in three hits. That’s why I never finished that game.

Does it preserve exactly enough? YES. Oath in Felghana is one of the best remakes I’ve seen; keeps everything good (classic story with expansion + music) and removes everything bad.

My favorite part of Ys3 immediately follows the scenes at the end of the Illburns ruins; that dungeon has the perfect music and good difficulty (goes from “okay maybe this is getting a little tough” to the perfect balance between challenge and playability). The feeling is replicated perfectly in Oath.

Your review says everything else I could possibly say.

12 years ago

I actually discovered Videolamer a couple of months ago because of Ys. In August, I saw that Ys book I and II was on the Wii Virtual Console, and remembered hearing good things about the series. It was cheap, so after I beat FFXIII, I downloaded it to wash the taste and confusion away. I was immediately hooked. Since then, I’ve only been able to add Ys IV: The Mask of the Sun to my least of beaten Ys’, but I would like to properly purchase and beat the others. I keep hoping Sony will put PSPs on a really compelling sale so I can justify buying one for the assorted Ys and Final Fantasy titles. Add in Lunar, and it seems like it’s really come into its own as an RPG platform.

And wasn’t there a King’s Field title for PSP? I used to be a -nut- for that little niche series.

Anyway, this remake of Ys III sounds more palatable than the original (anytime something is compared to Zelda II, I get -really- wary). It’s exciting to hear the original company handle the remake, and that final paragraph was a dream. I wish every remake could warrant just that description.

12 years ago

Hey, comments! These weren’t here last time I checked.

Thanks to Chris for those clarifications. I’m curious to see if Oath’s unlockable difficulty edges anywhere close to what you’re describing in Ys 3.

Marie, the PSP has very much matured as an RPG platform. That’s not to say that I’ve played all of them (or ever will), but the choices are there for sure. The upcoming releases of Tactics Ogre and (hopefully) Persona 2 next year add even more to the library. I’m not sure WHY we keep getting these games for a console that’s mostly dead in the West, but I won’t complain.